{ "csi-feedback-error-preview": { "allowLog": true, "description": "Absolute complex error for the same channel sample. Lower is better.", "series": [ { "color": "#2563eb", "dash": [ 7, 4 ], "id": "truncated_angular_delay", "label": "Truncated angular-delay", "marker": "square", "values": [ [ 0, 0.6506288051605225 ], [ 1, 0.545174777507782 ], [ 2, 0.4426984488964081 ], [ 3, 0.34546637535095215 ], [ 4, 0.25576886534690857 ], [ 5, 0.17566436529159546 ], [ 6, 0.10676765441894531 ], [ 7, 0.0501311793923378 ], [ 8, 0.007539977319538593 ], [ 9, 0.027298642322421074 ], [ 10, 0.048641711473464966 ], [ 11, 0.06117522343993187 ], [ 12, 0.0671408623456955 ], [ 13, 0.06923513114452362 ], [ 14, 0.07017945498228073 ], [ 15, 0.07210493087768555 ], [ 16, 0.07591159641742706 ], [ 17, 0.08116888999938965 ], [ 18, 0.08666957914829254 ], [ 19, 0.09105730056762695 ], [ 20, 0.09313587844371796 ], [ 21, 0.09192349761724472 ], [ 22, 0.086626335978508 ], [ 23, 0.0766335055232048 ], [ 24, 0.06158170849084854 ], [ 25, 0.04159560799598694 ], [ 26, 0.019161086529493332 ], [ 27, 0.022614557296037674 ], [ 28, 0.05424221605062485 ], [ 29, 0.09061059355735779 ], [ 30, 0.12827005982398987 ], [ 31, 0.1652202308177948 ] ] }, { "color": "#9333ea", "dash": [ 3, 3 ], "id": "matched_klt", "label": "Matched KLT/PCA", "marker": "diamond", "values": [ [ 0, 0.3708873987197876 ], [ 1, 0.3159649968147278 ], [ 2, 0.26039397716522217 ], [ 3, 0.2070891559123993 ], [ 4, 0.15966278314590454 ], [ 5, 0.12226749211549759 ], [ 6, 0.0985313281416893 ], [ 7, 0.08820954710245132 ], [ 8, 0.08514273911714554 ], [ 9, 0.08186403661966324 ], [ 10, 0.07399050146341324 ], [ 11, 0.06043006107211113 ], [ 12, 0.042967867106199265 ], [ 13, 0.029195668175816536 ], [ 14, 0.03590504452586174 ], [ 15, 0.05784301459789276 ], [ 16, 0.08186281472444534 ], [ 17, 0.10310308635234833 ], [ 18, 0.11933498084545135 ], [ 19, 0.1294732540845871 ], [ 20, 0.13334858417510986 ], [ 21, 0.13167279958724976 ], [ 22, 0.12599249184131622 ], [ 23, 0.1185208186507225 ], [ 24, 0.11168880015611649 ], [ 25, 0.10728807002305984 ], [ 26, 0.10551080107688904 ], [ 27, 0.10474735498428345 ], [ 28, 0.10243503004312515 ], [ 29, 0.09616851061582565 ], [ 30, 0.08445364981889725 ], [ 31, 0.06732743233442307 ] ] }, { "color": "#16a34a", "dash": [], "id": "learned_codec", "label": "Learned CSI codec", "marker": "circle", "values": [ [ 0, 0.3896193206310272 ], [ 1, 0.3339303433895111 ], [ 2, 0.2773977518081665 ], [ 3, 0.22213320434093475 ], [ 4, 0.17038686573505402 ], [ 5, 0.1243135929107666 ], [ 6, 0.08577930927276611 ], [ 7, 0.05624081939458847 ], [ 8, 0.03667191043496132 ], [ 9, 0.027160178869962692 ], [ 10, 0.025907723233103752 ], [ 11, 0.030494429171085358 ], [ 12, 0.03971391171216965 ], [ 13, 0.05221801996231079 ], [ 14, 0.06597495824098587 ], [ 15, 0.07879354059696198 ], [ 16, 0.08875124156475067 ], [ 17, 0.09448032081127167 ], [ 18, 0.09542565047740936 ], [ 19, 0.09215747565031052 ], [ 20, 0.08678604662418365 ], [ 21, 0.08324867486953735 ], [ 22, 0.08625250309705734 ], [ 23, 0.09789183735847473 ], [ 24, 0.11588569730520248 ], [ 25, 0.1359987109899521 ], [ 26, 0.15434560179710388 ], [ 27, 0.16801171004772186 ], [ 28, 0.1751103699207306 ], [ 29, 0.17486637830734253 ], [ 30, 0.16783398389816284 ], [ 31, 0.15630163252353668 ] ] } ], "title": "Representative complex reconstruction error", "type": "line", "xLabel": "Subcarrier index", "yIncludeZero": true, "yLabel": "Absolute complex error" }, "csi-feedback-nmse": { "allowLog": false, "description": "Lower is better. Perfect CSIT is omitted because its numerical error floor would compress the 128-bit comparison.", "series": [ { "color": "#2563eb", "dash": [ 7, 4 ], "id": "truncated_angular_delay", "label": "Truncated angular-delay", "marker": "square", "range": [ [ 0.0, -9.07559752456779, -8.531820401205543 ], [ 5.0, -9.07559752456779, -8.531820401205543 ], [ 10.0, -9.07559752456779, -8.531820401205543 ], [ 15.0, -9.07559752456779, -8.531820401205543 ], [ 20.0, -9.07559752456779, -8.531820401205543 ] ], "values": [ [ 0.0, -8.803708962886667 ], [ 5.0, -8.803708962886667 ], [ 10.0, -8.803708962886667 ], [ 15.0, -8.803708962886667 ], [ 20.0, -8.803708962886667 ] ] }, { "color": "#9333ea", "dash": [ 3, 3 ], "id": "matched_klt", "label": "Matched KLT/PCA", "marker": "diamond", "range": [ [ 0.0, -16.53225610417245, -16.15131233536088 ], [ 5.0, -16.53225610417245, -16.15131233536088 ], [ 10.0, -16.53225610417245, -16.15131233536088 ], [ 15.0, -16.53225610417245, -16.15131233536088 ], [ 20.0, -16.53225610417245, -16.15131233536088 ] ], "values": [ [ 0.0, -16.341784219766666 ], [ 5.0, -16.341784219766666 ], [ 10.0, -16.341784219766666 ], [ 15.0, -16.341784219766666 ], [ 20.0, -16.341784219766666 ] ] }, { "color": "#16a34a", "dash": [], "id": "learned_codec", "label": "Learned CSI codec", "marker": "circle", "range": [ [ 0.0, -16.548791228081644, -16.153060328185024 ], [ 5.0, -16.548791228081644, -16.153060328185024 ], [ 10.0, -16.548791228081644, -16.153060328185024 ], [ 15.0, -16.548791228081644, -16.153060328185024 ], [ 20.0, -16.548791228081644, -16.153060328185024 ] ], "values": [ [ 0.0, -16.350925778133334 ], [ 5.0, -16.350925778133334 ], [ 10.0, -16.350925778133334 ], [ 15.0, -16.350925778133334 ], [ 20.0, -16.350925778133334 ] ] } ], "title": "CSI reconstruction NMSE", "type": "line", "xLabel": "Downlink SNR (dB)", "yIncludeZero": false, "yLabel": "NMSE (dB)" }, "csi-feedback-rate": { "allowLog": true, "description": "All 128-bit methods and the non-deployable perfect-CSIT upper bound use the same paired held-out channel realizations.", "series": [ { "color": "#2563eb", "dash": [ 7, 4 ], "id": "truncated_angular_delay", "label": "Truncated angular-delay", "marker": "square", "range": [ [ 0.0, 3.0026534576306094, 3.0229458631027235 ], [ 5.0, 4.5270820268990555, 4.551650463634278 ], [ 10.0, 6.141332104666569, 6.167890434600098 ], [ 15.0, 7.78706032284845, 7.814413485438217 ], [ 20.0, 9.443146787802045, 9.470786648277956 ] ], "values": [ [ 0.0, 3.0127996603666665 ], [ 5.0, 4.539366245266667 ], [ 10.0, 6.1546112696333335 ], [ 15.0, 7.800736904143333 ], [ 20.0, 9.45696671804 ] ] }, { "color": "#9333ea", "dash": [ 3, 3 ], "id": "matched_klt", "label": "Matched KLT/PCA", "marker": "diamond", "range": [ [ 0.0, 3.0980454666875636, 3.1093813992057693 ], [ 5.0, 4.633906804230708, 4.647647735769292 ], [ 10.0, 6.25267801203878, 6.2673714010012205 ], [ 15.0, 7.900006573889458, 7.9150257493105425 ], [ 20.0, 9.556628164636919, 9.57175292870308 ] ], "values": [ [ 0.0, 3.1037134329466665 ], [ 5.0, 4.64077727 ], [ 10.0, 6.26002470652 ], [ 15.0, 7.9075161616 ], [ 20.0, 9.56419054667 ] ] }, { "color": "#16a34a", "dash": [], "id": "learned_codec", "label": "Learned CSI codec", "marker": "circle", "range": [ [ 0.0, 3.098614232572216, 3.108893218801117 ], [ 5.0, 4.634525587262004, 4.647119551797996 ], [ 10.0, 6.25331586673534, 6.266827324284659 ], [ 15.0, 7.900650763744928, 7.914476291108405 ], [ 20.0, 9.55727373506784, 9.571202089925494 ] ], "values": [ [ 0.0, 3.1037537256866665 ], [ 5.0, 4.64082256953 ], [ 10.0, 6.2600715955099995 ], [ 15.0, 7.9075635274266665 ], [ 20.0, 9.564237912496667 ] ] }, { "color": "#d97706", "dash": [ 10, 3 ], "id": "perfect_csit", "label": "Perfect CSIT", "marker": "triangle", "range": [ [ 0.0, 3.125607247625777, 3.136571809174223 ], [ 5.0, 4.664206675906866, 4.677427120779801 ], [ 10.0, 6.283978579773627, 6.298086048826373 ], [ 15.0, 7.931641415140674, 7.946048582212659 ], [ 20.0, 9.588371680568711, 9.602874352144623 ] ], "values": [ [ 0.0, 3.1310895284 ], [ 5.0, 4.670816898343333 ], [ 10.0, 6.2910323143 ], [ 15.0, 7.938844998676666 ], [ 20.0, 9.595623016356667 ] ] } ], "title": "Downlink spectral efficiency after CSI feedback", "type": "line", "xLabel": "Downlink SNR (dB)", "yIncludeZero": false, "yLabel": "Spectral efficiency (bit/s/Hz)" }, "csi-feedback-response-preview": { "allowLog": true, "description": "Transmit antenna 0, sample 0, 10 dB, paired seed 92001. Every deployable method uses the same 128-bit budget.", "series": [ { "color": "#d97706", "dash": [ 9, 3 ], "id": "true_channel", "label": "True channel magnitude", "marker": "triangle", "values": [ [ 0, 1.5175272226333618 ], [ 1, 1.3944792747497559 ], [ 2, 1.2750201225280762 ], [ 3, 1.1654001474380493 ], [ 4, 1.0713753700256348 ], [ 5, 0.9966632127761841 ], [ 6, 0.9415621161460876 ], [ 7, 0.9025976061820984 ], [ 8, 0.8736587166786194 ], [ 9, 0.8480871915817261 ], [ 10, 0.8206470012664795 ], [ 11, 0.7887026071548462 ], [ 12, 0.7525638341903687 ], [ 13, 0.7151801586151123 ], [ 14, 0.6812781095504761 ], [ 15, 0.6559216380119324 ], [ 16, 0.6426830887794495 ], [ 17, 0.6421709656715393 ], [ 18, 0.651902973651886 ], [ 19, 0.6676954030990601 ], [ 20, 0.6856380105018616 ], [ 21, 0.7036212682723999 ], [ 22, 0.7220046520233154 ], [ 23, 0.7434121370315552 ], [ 24, 0.7717270851135254 ], [ 25, 0.8105036020278931 ], [ 26, 0.8613641858100891 ], [ 27, 0.923146665096283 ], [ 28, 0.9921548366546631 ], [ 29, 1.06318998336792 ], [ 30, 1.130763053894043 ], [ 31, 1.1900851726531982 ] ] }, { "color": "#2563eb", "dash": [ 7, 4 ], "id": "truncated_angular_delay", "label": "Truncated angular-delay", "marker": "square", "values": [ [ 0, 1.0381606817245483 ], [ 1, 1.041757583618164 ], [ 2, 1.038236379623413 ], [ 3, 1.0276609659194946 ], [ 4, 1.0102252960205078 ], [ 5, 0.9862576127052307 ], [ 6, 0.9562286734580994 ], [ 7, 0.9207629561424255 ], [ 8, 0.8806563019752502 ], [ 9, 0.8369007706642151 ], [ 10, 0.7907179594039917 ], [ 11, 0.7435994148254395 ], [ 12, 0.6973497271537781 ], [ 13, 0.6541144847869873 ], [ 14, 0.6163544058799744 ], [ 15, 0.5867038369178772 ], [ 16, 0.5676462650299072 ], [ 17, 0.5610178709030151 ], [ 18, 0.5675076842308044 ], [ 19, 0.5864408016204834 ], [ 20, 0.6159909963607788 ], [ 21, 0.6536785960197449 ], [ 22, 0.6968690752983093 ], [ 23, 0.7430984377861023 ], [ 24, 0.7902178764343262 ], [ 25, 0.8364191651344299 ], [ 26, 0.8802073001861572 ], [ 27, 0.9203585386276245 ], [ 28, 0.9558783173561096 ], [ 29, 0.9859686493873596 ], [ 30, 1.0100035667419434 ], [ 31, 1.0275107622146606 ] ] }, { "color": "#9333ea", "dash": [ 3, 3 ], "id": "matched_klt", "label": "Matched KLT/PCA", "marker": "diamond", "values": [ [ 0, 1.1781868934631348 ], [ 1, 1.1151971817016602 ], [ 2, 1.0538197755813599 ], [ 3, 0.9956740736961365 ], [ 4, 0.9421915411949158 ], [ 5, 0.8945134282112122 ], [ 6, 0.8534001111984253 ], [ 7, 0.8191691637039185 ], [ 8, 0.7916727066040039 ], [ 9, 0.7703261375427246 ], [ 10, 0.7541831135749817 ], [ 11, 0.7420457005500793 ], [ 12, 0.7325947880744934 ], [ 13, 0.7245246171951294 ], [ 14, 0.7166743874549866 ], [ 15, 0.7081537842750549 ], [ 16, 0.6984634399414062 ], [ 17, 0.6876100301742554 ], [ 18, 0.6762039661407471 ], [ 19, 0.6655208468437195 ], [ 20, 0.657487154006958 ], [ 21, 0.6545313000679016 ], [ 22, 0.659258246421814 ], [ 23, 0.6739606261253357 ], [ 24, 0.700101375579834 ], [ 25, 0.737982451915741 ], [ 26, 0.7867444753646851 ], [ 27, 0.8446523547172546 ], [ 28, 0.9094950556755066 ], [ 29, 0.9789342284202576 ], [ 30, 1.050734519958496 ], [ 31, 1.1228796243667603 ] ] }, { "color": "#16a34a", "dash": [], "id": "learned_codec", "label": "Learned CSI codec", "marker": "circle", "values": [ [ 0, 1.2260544300079346 ], [ 1, 1.1757068634033203 ], [ 2, 1.1259169578552246 ], [ 3, 1.07767915725708 ], [ 4, 1.031907081604004 ], [ 5, 0.989337146282196 ], [ 6, 0.9504368901252747 ], [ 7, 0.9153556227684021 ], [ 8, 0.88392174243927 ], [ 9, 0.8557141423225403 ], [ 10, 0.830180287361145 ], [ 11, 0.8067878484725952 ], [ 12, 0.78517085313797 ], [ 13, 0.7652413845062256 ], [ 14, 0.7472524046897888 ], [ 15, 0.7317996621131897 ], [ 16, 0.7197609543800354 ], [ 17, 0.7121905088424683 ], [ 18, 0.7101751565933228 ], [ 19, 0.7146857380867004 ], [ 20, 0.7264507412910461 ], [ 21, 0.7458745837211609 ], [ 22, 0.773017406463623 ], [ 23, 0.8076146841049194 ], [ 24, 0.849122166633606 ], [ 25, 0.8967608213424683 ], [ 26, 0.9495528340339661 ], [ 27, 1.006353735923767 ], [ 28, 1.0658836364746094 ], [ 29, 1.1267685890197754 ], [ 30, 1.1875954866409302 ], [ 31, 1.2469735145568848 ] ] } ], "title": "Representative reconstructed CSI magnitude", "type": "line", "xLabel": "Subcarrier index", "yIncludeZero": true, "yLabel": "Channel magnitude" }, "csi-feedback-retention": { "allowLog": false, "description": "Achieved MRT rate divided by perfect-CSIT MRT rate on the same channel realization.", "series": [ { "color": "#2563eb", "dash": [ 7, 4 ], "id": "truncated_angular_delay", "label": "Truncated angular-delay", "marker": "square", "range": [ [ 0.0, 0.9601307748364597, 0.964310576320207 ], [ 5.0, 0.9702093221190564, 0.9735044839529436 ], [ 10.0, 0.976995817763274, 0.9796339629620594 ], [ 15.0, 0.9815249420978479, 0.9836819525614854 ], [ 20.0, 0.9846477657019358, 0.9864523169647309 ] ], "values": [ [ 0.0, 0.9622206755783334 ], [ 5.0, 0.971856903036 ], [ 10.0, 0.9783148903626667 ], [ 15.0, 0.9826034473296666 ], [ 20.0, 0.9855500413333333 ] ] }, { "color": "#9333ea", "dash": [ 3, 3 ], "id": "matched_klt", "label": "Matched KLT/PCA", "marker": "diamond", "range": [ [ 0.0, 0.9908061655519657, 0.9917072019160343 ], [ 5.0, 0.9932321779344431, 0.9939051268968901 ], [ 10.0, 0.9948119694074701, 0.9953302577698634 ], [ 15.0, 0.9958458339583256, 0.9962616194483411 ], [ 20.0, 0.9965517326428317, 0.9968969125978351 ] ], "values": [ [ 0.0, 0.991256683734 ], [ 5.0, 0.9935686524156666 ], [ 10.0, 0.9950711135886667 ], [ 15.0, 0.9960537267033334 ], [ 20.0, 0.9967243226203334 ] ] }, { "color": "#16a34a", "dash": [], "id": "learned_codec", "label": "Learned CSI codec", "marker": "circle", "range": [ [ 0.0, 0.9908387827603021, 0.9917003834990311 ], [ 5.0, 0.9932631439045104, 0.9938935938861563 ], [ 10.0, 0.9948374707179215, 0.9953196849507451 ], [ 15.0, 0.9958668527456934, 0.9962525474923066 ], [ 20.0, 0.9965692959626813, 0.9968892314333186 ] ], "values": [ [ 0.0, 0.9912695831296666 ], [ 5.0, 0.9935783688953334 ], [ 10.0, 0.9950785778343333 ], [ 15.0, 0.996059700119 ], [ 20.0, 0.996729263698 ] ] }, { "color": "#d97706", "dash": [ 10, 3 ], "id": "perfect_csit", "label": "Perfect CSIT", "marker": "triangle", "range": [ [ 0.0, 1.0, 1.0 ], [ 5.0, 1.0, 1.0 ], [ 10.0, 0.9999998659895927, 1.0000000834657408 ], [ 15.0, 1.0, 1.0 ], [ 20.0, 0.9999998905721063, 1.0000001756945605 ] ], "values": [ [ 0.0, 1.0 ], [ 5.0, 1.0 ], [ 10.0, 0.9999999747276667 ], [ 15.0, 1.0 ], [ 20.0, 1.0000000331333334 ] ] } ], "title": "Perfect-CSIT downlink rate retained", "type": "line", "xLabel": "Downlink SNR (dB)", "yIncludeZero": false, "yLabel": "Rate retention" } }